17. All Rights Reserved. Furthermore, they assume that although the Torah did not identify the Tree, it provided clues through which the careful reader can deduce its identity. Many assume that the forbidden Tree was a recognizable, natural tree whose produce was forbidden in the Garden of Eden and when consumed it had a supernatural effect, yet today the tree’s fruit is permitted to be consumed. Where did the idea come from that the forbidden fruit in the Garden of Eden was an apple? Would love your thoughts, please comment. While more common in Christian art, it can be found in Jewish sources as well. He says that an etrog in Aramaic means chemda (desirous), perhaps alluding to the sin.5 Ramban adds that the mitzvah of arba minim is to atone for the sin in the Garden of Eden that occurred with the etrog. Wheat is not usually eaten raw. It isn’t literally an Apple. Genesis just says "fruit." What do you think of the answers? In most European Christian. An Adam’s apple, the laryngeal prominence on the human neck (mostly found on males) is named either because it looks as if a piece of the apple got lodged there or, more likely, because it is a round bulge. The Midrash says that when one lacks intelligence, others comment that he has not eaten wheat bread. However, I do not suggest that this was the reason Eve knew the fruit to be edible. The "apple" thing must have come from another ancient mythology --- that of the Greeks. Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. Furthermore, they assume that although the Torah did not identify the Tree, it provided clues through which the careful reader can deduce its identity. is there any truth to david ickes claims? Discover the official reproduction of the Apple of Eden from the Assassin''s Creed movie. Were Christians really thrown to the lions? The story stated it was the fruit of the tree of knowledge. These assumptions are not necessarily accepted by all. The Sages understood that the same object with which they sinned was used to begin to repair the consequences of the sin. apart from altierder who I belive is christan because of the fact he could hold and control the apple due to the fact the fall(adem and eve) was christian so I think the reson that the Templar's wanted it is because they wanted to destroy the thing that god said would give all bad knowledge of man kind to please him. The word evil in the tree's name in Latin is mali (Genesis 2:17). In the early Jewish sources there is no mention of an apple, and furthermore, in the Jewish tradition, the apple usually has a positive connotation and is associated with sweetness, not sin.10 There are several suggestions as to how the apple came to be associated with the Forbidden Fruit. The generic fruit: For most of history, the words used today to connote an apple (“apple,” “tapuach,” “pomme” in French, “pomum” in Latin) were words that denoted a generic fruit or a round object.14 The Mishnah (Tamid 2:2) calls the large pile of ashes in the center of the altar “tapuach” and the Rosh explains that anything gathered together and piled high is called tapuach.15 The pile of grapes in a wine press is referred to as a tapuach (Avodah Zarah  55a), as are the heel of a foot (Vayikra Rabbah 20) and the gold and silver round bells on a sefer Torah (Shulchan Aruch, YD 282:16). Later Suggestions: The Holy One, blessed be He, never revealed [the identity of] that Tree to any person, and He never will.’”20. Known in Spanish as “, —Adam’s fig—the sabra was associated with the fruit of the Garden of Eden. Yaakov brought it in: When Yaakov entered to receive the blessing from his father Yitzchak while wearing the clothes of his brother Esav, “[Yitzchak] smelled the fragrance of his garments, and blessed him. The Holy One, blessed be He, never revealed [the identity of] that Tree to any person, and He never will.’”. 3 (which was modeled after several fruits), As shown in A is for Adam (one of the best children’s books on Genesis). 5. The other Sages seemingly did not agree with Rabbi Azariah and Rabbi Yehudah Bar Simon, as they did not hesitate to try to discover the identity (although their discussions may have been more about drawing out various ethical lessons than verifying the Tree’s actual identity). Seemingly, in Biblical and rabbinic sources, the word tapuach refers to an etrog. 21. The best of The Straight Dope, delivered to your inbox. Where you glad your parents told you Santa was real as a kid or not? These statements provide a basis for concluding that the “Tree of Knowledge” was actually wheat.